Category Archives: writing

Mind Exchange is Fantasy Not SF

The final indignity for the original series of Star Trek was the episode Turnabout Intruder where a bitter woman, Janice Lester, used trickery and an alien device to swap bodies with Captain James T. Kirk generating some of the series most over the top performances from William Shatner.

The body swap, a fantastical process where one person’s mind is placed into the body of another is tired trope and one that should always be understood as fantasy not science-fiction.

The core erroneous concept for this idea is that there is a separation between body and mind, that our ‘selves’ exist independent of our bodies and thus could be transplanted into a new form like a sapling being moved to a larger pot.

Our minds are emergent properties of our bodies. The subtle and complex interactions of physical experience, hormonal balances, and genetics give rise to the varied and unique personalities of the human race. There is not independent mind to move from one body to another. It is the body that generates the mind and with a different body, or a significantly altered one, the mind is different. Numerous brain injury and disease cases bear witness to this fact of life.

All of that said, I think I have found at least one, far out but barely plausible method of telling a body swap story. Now to see if I can make it work.

Share

The Joys of Revisiting a Manuscript

For reasons too extensive to go into here I am revisiting a novel length manuscript I last opened in November of 2014. This novel, at the suggestion of an agency, went through a major change in 2015 and that revised version has been the version sent to various people. Now I am taking the opportunity to go back to my original vision and use it for a different submission.

Originally, I went in for the prosaic task of turning all the underlined text into the house’s preferred format italics which required carefully reading every page of the novel to make sure I didn’t miss an instance. This led to the discovery that this earlier, longer version of the story is also before I changed the name of one of the major military ships that appear in the story, Okay, so now I am not only fixing underlines with italics but I’m watching for the old name so I can replace it with the new one.

Of course, my writing a changed over the last five and a half years, hopefully for the better, and I am finding the odd sentence where I need to massage it a little to get it to where I am today in terms of style and voice.

Then I discover an error that somehow slipped past all my earlier edits, my beta readers, and everyone else who has taken a gander at the manuscript. Reggie leave Geneva under the light of a full moon; the same night Seth in Spain is getting ready for what he hopes will be a romantic evening under a new moon. Glad I caught that one!

Still, my most common reaction to re-reading and working on this manuscript has been joy. This is the sort of book I love to read and while there are minor edits taking place, I am very happy with the prose and love revisiting my original vision.

Share

Quick Post

So, I missed posting on Monday and Tuesday because over the weekend I came down with some sort of sinus bug. No, it’s not Covid-19, but some rather short duration but fairly intense clogging of my sinuses that left me dizzy, congested, headachy, and generally non-functional.

Saturday I was fine, running my Space Opera RPG game but as the evening ended and I departed for home my head started to hurt. By the time I reached home, just 5 miles away, it was a fairly serious migraine, and Sunday I canceled on going to the zoo with my sweetie-wife leading to a convalesce that lasted through Monday and Tuesday.

So, my weekend and the first part of my week has not been very productive. I did manage to get some more editing completed on a manuscript I am about to send to my editor at Flame Tree and I watched a few films, re-watching 1993’s Searching for Bobby Fischer which I enjoy quite a bit.

 

Share

This Feels Wrong

This will be a quick post.

So, I am revising my military SF about an American serving in the European Union’s Star Forces set in a future in which America took a wrong turn in the early 21st century and became a second-rate power. Honest, I was cooking this idea back in the early 90s.

This is the manuscript that originally clocked in at 115 thousand words and on advice from an agency was trimmed to around 98 thousand.

As I review the original longer work, a version I had preferred, I find that I am really enjoying this book. It has been a few years since I have read it carefully, line by line, word by word, as once I send a project off to editors for consideration, I protect my sanity by moving on to the next project. So, this return to the origi9nal manuscript is a, pardon the pun, novel experience.

It feels wrong just how much I am enjoying this read. But this speaks to the truism I hold to in writing, write the book you want to read. There is your vision, there is voice, there is what makes it yours.

 

Share

Treacherous Seas

In less than a month my debut novel Vulcan’s Forge will be released upon an unsuspecting world. My editor at Flame Tree has expressed the hopes in the future that we shall be working together on many novels. I have found everyone at Flame Tree to be wonderful, supportive, and utterly professional and welcoming so the idea of working with them on more books is very enticing.

Some years ago, I completed a military SF novel that landed me with a literary agency. While the association with the agency didn’t work out and we went our separate ways, that novel has sparked at least some interest with a couple of publishing houses.

The trouble is timing.

Two other editors are looking at the book, one because we met a conference and they read a few sample pages and the other because I had submitted the manuscript through the imprint’s slush pile. (Slush pile is the name for the great stack of manuscript that are sent to a publisher un-agented.) Both publishers have had the book for over a year now. In that interim I sold, edited, and next both will have published Vulcan’s Forge with Flame tree.

I have decided that I am going to go ahead and send my military SF book over to Flame Tree. I will let the other editors know what the score is but I can’t even be sure that my emails are being read. These are turbulent seas to navigate and the sort where having an agent would be extremely helpful but I have no agent and must sail these waters myself.

I am taking some time to revise the manuscript before sending it over the Flame Tree. When I submitted to that agency I was signed with it was 115,000 words long, not overly long for an SF novel, but the reader and co—owner of the agency had required that I cut it down before he recommended it to his agents and so I brought it down to 98,000 words. I did this by trimming the opening battle but I was never truly happy with that. The massive battle that opens the book is meant to have the scale, weight, and importance of something along the lines of WWII’s battle of Midway and the lighter version I felt didn’t quite get that across. So, I am going back to the 115,000 words manuscript, making minor adjustments and that will by the new version.

Wish me luck.

 

Share

My Long Weekend

This past weekend was a very satisfying one for me. Thursday, I traveled to Disneyland and hung out with a friend I have not seen for a few years. The original plan was to be with two pals but financial issue at the last moment grounded one of my friends. We hung about in Galaxy’s Edge, though we did not get a boarding Pass that would have allowed us onto the newest attracting, explored other areas of the park, and had a smashing good time getting caught up on each other’s lives. After about 7 hours of walking my knees sent their vehement protests and we called it day so I could drive home to San Diego.

Friday through Saturday I spent at the 34th annual Southern California Writers Conference. This is the third time I have attended the particular conference and it is small intimate gathering of writers and agents to share the craft. There were many good seminars and workshops during the daylight hours and in the evening I participated in read and critique sessions giving my meager opinion on some fantastic writing. I got valuable feedback on a work in progress of mine and all in all had a great time with friends and expanded my skill set.

The Conference continued into Sunday, but I skipped out on the last day not because it had suddenly turned dull but because I wanted to spend my Sunday in my traditional manner, with my sweetie-wife. We did not go to the zoo, perhaps just as well as I feel I may have pushed my knees a bit far, had a lovely lunch at one of our favorite spots, and generally enjoyed each other’s company.

Here’s hoping your weekend was similarly enjoyable.

Share

Naming My Characters

Coming up with names for characters in my short stories and novel has always been a challenge. There’s the desire to avoid names with feel too ‘common’ and lack their own sense of character, the Bobs and so forth, but going too far afield into actual names that are exceptionally rare feels false. This is a    hurdle I have to overcome with every piece of fiction, no matter how long or how brief and can be magnified if the character in question is an alien because before I can name the character I have to devise a naming system for his culture because after all individual name plus family name isn’t even universal among humans.

For my novel being published next month I managed to make this difficult task even harder.

The set-up in the novel is that when the Earth is threatened with destruction by a rouge brown dwarf passing through the inner solar system humanity launches hundreds if not thousands of automated arks loaded with self-replicating machines, artificial wombs, and banks of sperm and egg to establish new human colonies. Some of these arks were programmed with very specific goals of persevering certain cultures, nationalities, and religion and so forth, some were designed to have a greater degree of freedom in the care of the generations of humans that were to follow.

For the colony of Nocturnia where the novel takes place the demographic percentages of the later 21st century America were used to create the racial make-up of the colony and the names were taken from the U.S. Census but in drafting the outline and creating the character I faced a decision that swung me back and forth for quite some time.

Should the character names be tied to their character’s ethnicity?

These characters had never in any sense at all be a product of the cultures that their names derived from for all intents and purposes they were faux-Americans. With their ark’s designers fixated on an idealized American culture that never truly existed would that have programmed the artificial intelligences to force names to match ethnic background or simply have left the assignment of names to the A.I. own randomness?

I liked the idea that the names were randomly assigned but I was concerned that the readers might be lost of confused. I wanted to avoid leaning too heavily on reminding the reader just what each character’s ethnic heritage was and if I kept the names tied to their heritage I could side-step the challenge. But once I hit on the idea of the randomness of the names I really really liked it.

In the end I went the character names that do not map to their racial appearance. Now with the book coming out next month and should reviews and feedback come back my direction I will learn if I met the challenge or faceplanted.

 

Share

Movies Better Than Their Books

It’s a sentiment accepted by many a bibliophile that the novel is always better than the film version, but I content such a broad and all-encompassing statement cannot be universally true. Here are a few examples of where I think the films version of the stories exceeded what the novel presented.

Jaws

The iconic terrifying film from Steven Spielberg sent a generation scrambling for the shore fearful of the water is based upon a novel by Peter Benchley. For the screenplay two major sub-plots were omitted, the affair between Chief Brody’s wife and the young expert Hooper and Amity’s Mayor’s debt to local organized crime that made the mayor fearful of closing the beaches and being unable to repay what he owed. Both sub-plots are melodramatic and easily the most forgettable aspects of the novel. While Hooper’s and Ellen’s affair makes both of these characters less sympathetic than the cinematic characters.

The Hunt for Red October

Tom Clancy’s first novel of a Soviet super-sub’s defection to the west produced a terrific film directed by John McTernan and gave us the best on-screen Jack Ryan with Alec Baldwin. The novel suffered from American Uber Alles with everything done by the U.S. Military being exemplary over the far less capable Soviet forces. Reducing this produced a tighter and more tense conflict.

The Prestige

Not as well-know or as beloved as many other films by Christopher Nolan The Prestige took the great liberties with its source material a prize-winning fantasy novel of the same name by Christopher Priest. The novel spans time between the modern day, 1995 for the publication date, and the later 1800 with the feud between the rival stage magicians, introducing concepts as far afield as ghost into its narrative. Nolan’s script simplified the scope, restricting to its time setting, but retaining the multiple points of view and non-linear narrative but most importantly his gave a better motivation for why the feus turned murderous. In the novel it spirals out from one character performing seances, a common practice for stage magician’s, and being exposed for his fraud by his rival, also a common activity for stage magicians of the period. Having an on-stage death for which one is responsible made for a more compelling and acceptable motivation for the feud’s terrible escalation.

 

Share

Thoughts About Prologs

One of the most common pieces of advice  you’re likely to hear at seminars, workshops, conventions, and writing groups is that publishers and agents do not want to see prologs. This is a true statement that is often countered by pointing to numerous books that currently sit on shelves with prologs. Of course, as a counter example that is not a very good argument because it suffers from survivor bias, the only books that sit on booksellers’ shelving are the book that were published a tiny fraction of the novel written and a tiny fraction of those submitted for consideration to agents and publishers.

Why is there such an often-repeated suggestion to omit your prolog? It is because far too many prologs are nothing more than either world building or backstory establishment where authors fearful that the readers will be lost create to explain the opening situation and there in a single word is why these prologs are weak openings, ‘explain.’

When you start your novel you have a very limited window to grab the reader’s attention and starting out with an explanation tends to lack dramatic tension. Agents and editors, people with little time and a very tall stack of things to read will smell an obvious explanation focused opening and from that deduce that the writer is unlikely to handle the rest of the story well and stop reading. Casual readers may give you more space but aside from self-publishing you must first survived the fires of the agents and editors to reach that larger audience.

I have a novel coming out next month, Vulcan’s Forge and to much amusement from members of my writers’ group it has a prolog. However, when I first wrote the novel it did not. After the first round of beta readers one of the more common comments centered of confusion about events that had happened prior to the start of the story. Because Vulcan’s Forge is written in a first-person point of view, I had two options to fix the issue. I could have characters that were there tell the point of view character what happened much like how a detective in some novels will gather everyone together for the resolution of the mystery, or I could show the events in a prolog. Clearly, I went with the prolog and clearly it did not cause my editor to bounce the manuscript, but I think there were a couple of factors that helped my novel survive the issue around having a prolog.

To start with the prolog is presented in third person. This cleanly breaks it away from the rest of the novel setting the tone that there is much that the main character is unaware of and that presents a danger to him. Next the prolog itself is a scene of dramatic tension with a viewpoint character that faces a tribulation and suffers its resolution. The vital information that my beta readers felt was missing is presented in the context of characters in conflict and not direct exposition. And finally, the prolog ends with a dramatic hook that leads directly into the opening scene of the novel so that the reader but not the character is aware of the importance of the story opening sequence.

Prologs can work but you must understand the purpose of your prolog and you must always wrap it in dramatic narrative if it is to be seen as essential to your piece.

Share

The Trouble with Screenplay Credits

If you watch movie made in the united states you know that right before the Director’s Credit, contractually the final credit displayed before the film plays, you will see the credit for the writer of the screenplay. You may see a single person credited, or several. If there’s an ampersand between two names it means those people are a team and if there’s an and it means one person wrote and then the other came along and also wrote but they did not work together. This is all well and good but in the end it seems like it’s not really the whole truth of the matter.

The writer is employed at the whim and dictates of the producer and in the film that has such a large impact that it makes it very difficult for anyone outside of the process that made that particular film to know just what elements of the screenplay are the result of the writer and which are elements that were forced into the work by some other agency. The writer may be against have a giant mutant worm sexually assault a female character but if the producer insists on the scene then it will be written and shot and for the rest of time the writer will be the one carrying the credit and the blame for the exploitive sequence. The director may be a hired gun for the production with little interest in the material who throws out the final act and writes his own ending, but it will be the credited screenwriters who are blamed for ripping off Aliens for their script.

When you watch a movie it can be nearly impossible to know who is actually responsible for both the great and terrible elements of the story and that’s a problem in my book. I wish I had some solution, but I don’t. The truth of the matter is that the final product is what it is and the credits may give you a clue as to how it came to be and its potential quality but only a clue.

 

Share