Envy, is That You?

.

On this week’s episode of Scriptnotes, a podcast about screenwriting and things interesting to screenwriters, the hosts, John August (Big Fish, Go, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory) and Craig Mazin (Chernobyl, The Last of Us, The Sheep Detectives), started a series looking at the seven deadly sins and their applications both to characters and to the lives of writers, kicking with envy.

There is a demarcation between the often-conflated concepts of envy and jealousy. Jealousy is the emotion associated with someone taking away from you something that you treasure, the jealous husband fearful that the young handsome shark expert will steal away his wife, while envy is the emotion associated with the strong desire to possess what someone else already has, the beautiful sex worker with the heart of gold who has given that heart to a fellow, but brutish, police officer.

For the past day I have been pondering a debate between this pair of talented and accomplished writers. John believed that there was a positive side to envy, that looking at another person’s success could help motivate and propel someone to achieve it for themselves, that seeing someone land that deal might push a writer to finish their big scary project and chase a similar outcome. Craig, on the other hand, felt that envy is wrapped up with resentment. For it to be envy as he understood it, required that not only did this other person have what you wanted but that they did not deserve to possess it. I leaned heavily towards Craig’s argument, but John’s pestered me for the rest of the day and into this morning. It sounded plausible and yet it felt entirely erroneous, but why?

I have spent time applying their arguments to my own life and my own experiences. As a writer of short stories and novels, I have not had the success at traditional publishing that I desire. A few short stories here and there and one novel that had the terrible misfortune of being released just as the world shuttered its doors due to a global pandemic. I have friends, who, when we first met, were as unpublished as I was, and have found tremendous success with their writing, massive sales, landing on national and recognized best seller lists, critical and commercial success.

Am I envious of them?

If envy requires resentment, then the answer is a clear and unequivocal no. Even in the dark of night, when depression comes like a stealthy monster from the blackest nightmares, I have not resented their success or their talent. I am truly and fully happy for them, and each new success of theirs honestly warms my heart and brightens my day.

But what of John’s argument? Does their success spur me onward to keep chasing mine? Does it make mine seem more possible?

It does, but this is where I think John August got tangled up in what he was thinking about, conflating two different emotional states in much the same manner that people conflate jealousy and envy. John confused envy with inspiration.

The work, both the prose and the success, of my friends has inspired and challenged me to push the envelope of my own skill, to keep battering at the wall of rejection and to, most important of all, keep dreaming. It has never put a dark thought in my head that they somehow did not deserve their success, something I believe is a core element of true envy.

Envy is not just about what they have and you do not. It is tangled up with that terrible corrosive certainty that it should have never been theirs at all. Do I get depressed when things do not work out, when an agent praises my writing skills but still passes on the proposed project? Oh yes, depression and futility stalk my dark nights, but never resentment of my friends, and that, to me, is the clearest sign that Craig, and not John, is correct about the sin of envy.

Share

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.