A trope I am tired of seeing …

Saturday night a friend and I sat down and watch the 2013 re-make of Carrie, based on King’s novel. The film was a very good adaptation, though it has been a long time since I read the book, I thought that the writers and filmmakers had captured the characters, tone, and heart of the piece.

Of course you can’t delve into Carrie without getting into one of king’s favorite tropes: the crazy christian character (C3.) He uses the C3 over and over again, plus he is not alone. The C3 is an overused stereotype through hollywood and television. Now, I am myself not a Christian. I am of the opinion that all regions look wacky from the outside and I seem to be outside all of them. HoweverI am a writer and I really get tired of seeing lazy, ignorant work.

The C3 is a lazy, stupid, stereotype, These ‘characters’ can very nearly be picked up and dropped in replacing other C3s in a plot and not one thing would really change. They are rarely handled with any sense on an individual with agency and background. as with Nazis, they are go-to bad guys that are used for plot connivence.

As I said before I am not a christian, this is not me taking personal offense at a stereotype. it is the artist in my really sick of the hack work. When we pay money for a piece of commercial art, we deserve the very best the artist could do at that moment, and the C3 is not the very best for many of these artist.

It is important for a writer to treat all the characters as fully realized human beings, with faults and talent, with hopes and dreams, with pain and joy.

 

Share

3 thoughts on “A trope I am tired of seeing …

  1. Bob Evans Post author

    There are violent Muslims, but that scarcely justifies writing only “dirke Dirke Jihad!” stereotypes.
    There swishy effeminate gays, that doesn’t justify over the top sissy portrayals of gay people.
    There are young-earthers and other creationists, that doesn’t justify the C3 trope.
    It is still, in my opinion, nothing more than lazy, hack writing.

  2. Missy

    I think part of the issue is that there is a REAL Crazy Christian Community out there and we have ALL run into them from time to time. If there were fewer crazy Christians, then this would not be the go-to vehicle to move story around. Darned shame, really.

  3. Tom

    To be fair, he does usually do them justice in the book(s). I’ll go with “tv/movie translations of the C3 never have enough background to not suck.”

Comments are closed.