Michelle Malkin Loves Communists.

So if you follow political columnist at all then you should already be familiar with Michelle Malkin. Ms. Malkin  is a very conservative opinion writer. She’s known for fiery opinions defended aggressively with a penchant for name-calling.  Ms. Malkin’s frequent posting are aggressive, and in-your-face which has earned her plenty of die-hard supporters and an equal number of die hard critics.

I am in neither camp. I do not care for name calling and I feel whenever you you do so in an argument you do nothing but weaken your case. I find her blog to be depressing. There is very little joy in her posts and nearly every post is about something that has offended, enraged, or irritated her. That’s fine if that is what she wants. It’s her blog and she can put up anything she likes, but it make for a repetitive and angry tone. I seriously can not think of a post that was truly just happy or joyous.

I frequent her site because it is a very good reflection of where conservative thought and feelings are for a number of subjects.

For a woman who like to call people to the left or her Socialists and Communists I have been surprised lately with her love affair for Communism. Thought I am sure it is one born out of ignorance.

Recently she’s been posting that Conservatives need to have an “I am Spartacus” moment of resistance to the health care reform, base on the stunning scene from the movie “Spartacus“.

Here’s the scene:

Spartacus is one of my favorite films and I will be so happy in a few months when I have it on DVD, but the film is a communist allegory.
The film was based on the novel Spartacus written by Howard Fast, who was a communist. I don’t mean that in the current Republican way of anyone left of me is a communist, Mr. Fast was a member of the American Communist Party. He was so hot politically no publisher would touch the novel Spartacus and he was forced to self-publish it. On the audio commentary to the Laserdisc of Spartacus Mr. Fast made it clear that the story was a communist allegory about the rich and the workers.

The film screenplay was adapted by Dalton Trumbo, another Communist.  Trumbo spent 11 years in prison for contempt of congress for refusing to testify before the House Un-American Activities Committee.  Spartacus was the first film he was credited with writing after the blacklist. (Thoigh he had written many just denied credit.) He was proud of having killed films in Hollywood that were deemed anti-communist.

I have no doubt that if either man was still alive today they would happy tell Ms. Malkin that in their view she and her fellow conservatives are more aligned with Marcus Licinius Crassus than with the workers uprising symbolized by the slave revolt in Spartacus. (To be clear I am not a communists and I ignore the communist allegory of Spartacus, but then I am not trying to lift the film for my own political ends either.)

I am deeply amused by the irony that a communist hater is aligning herself with communist writers and with what they saw as communist characters.

Share

5 thoughts on “Michelle Malkin Loves Communists.”

  1. Simply commentling on “Sparicus” (Which is also an AMAZING ballet, originally staged in the then Communist USSR by the Bolshoi and also – I think – by the Kirov! Absolutely brilliant!! If you get the chance, go see it!! I saw the first, full, United States performance with the Orlando Ballet Theater, then under the art direction of Bujones! Wonderful, with very few artistic problems.) Anyway, sorry for that, but I anted to ask about two points – did the director and writer have anything to say about the deeply Christian message that is also in the film and do they see the struggle of the worker as ultimately doomed, at least in the short term since they are all crucified? Should there have been a spoiler alert? Please wiggle this, if you feel there is need.

    1. I think any christian message you see is one from your own interpretations. Remember that the romans used crucifixions for a long time before christ and that the romans got it from asia. (Though in the east the shape of the cruciform was in an ‘x’ not a ‘t’.) Not every guy nailed to two pieces of wood is a christ metaphor. 🙂

    1. I am deeply amused by the irony that a communist hater is aligning herself with communist writers and with what they saw as communist characters. I’m not sure how you view that sentiment as an attack.

Comments are closed.